{
  "recorded_at": "2026-10-29T03:36:02.534+00:00",
  "historical_model": "deepseek-flash",
  "original_route": "d / original (historical experiment route; not product V1–V3)",
  "query": "参考右图双系列进度图的表达方式，让原图的步数趋势更有对比感；不要虚构任何运动数据，也不要丢掉连接手环手表的入口。",
  "question": "原图只有一组步数数据，参考的第二条序列该如何落地：做浅色量程底槽，还是只加深单柱深浅？",
  "initial_scope": {
    "borrow": [
      "从 参考图 #1 借用周进度柱状图",
      "从 参考图 #1 借用图表系列图例",
      "从 参考图 #1 借用蛋白质橙色图例、碳水枚红图例"
    ],
    "apply": [
      "九根单柱改为九组双层圆头柱，柱高仍按原值",
      "实柱改深玫红，底槽保留浅青，形成双色对比",
      "柱形上方新增双色图例：步数与量程参照",
      "实柱为区内最抢眼元素，底槽与图例退为辅助"
    ],
    "preserve": [
      "连接手环手表入口保持可点击",
      "入口文字不变，仍为连接手环手表",
      "柱形只表达原有步数，不新增或改写数值",
      "标题、说明、图表、入口的板块从属不变",
      "卡片浅青渐变底与圆角保持",
      "按钮描边色与胶囊圆角保持",
      "设备按钮仍位于柱形下方"
    ],
    "assign": [
      "周进度柱状图作用于步数柱形图",
      "图表系列图例作用于步数柱形区",
      "蛋白质橙色图例、碳水枚红图例作用于步数柱形图"
    ],
    "ambiguities": [
      "原图只有一组步数数据，参考的第二条序列该如何落地：做浅色量程底槽，还是只加深单柱深浅？"
    ],
    "confidence": 0.82,
    "item_confidence": {
      "borrow": [
        0.85,
        0.8,
        0.8
      ],
      "assign": [
        0.82,
        0.78,
        0.8
      ],
      "apply": [
        0.82,
        0.8,
        0.78,
        0.78
      ],
      "preserve": [
        0.95,
        0.95,
        0.9,
        0.9,
        0.85,
        0.9,
        0.88
      ]
    },
    "ambiguity_suggestions": {
      "原图只有一组步数数据，参考的第二条序列该如何落地：做浅色量程底槽，还是只加深单柱深浅？": "已采用实柱加深色、浅青量程底槽的双层柱并配双色图例，不引入任何新数据"
    }
  },
  "clarification": "采用单系列圆头柱，只借用参考的柱形质感；不增加量程底槽、图例或第二指标，不虚构数值。其他卡片要求与连接手环手表入口保留。",
  "confirmed_scope": {
    "borrow": [
      "从 参考图 #1 借用图表卡大圆角",
      "从 参考图 #1 借用柱形均匀分布"
    ],
    "apply": [
      "柱顶收成饱满圆头，柱身圆润统一",
      "九柱等距排列，间距一致，趋势起伏更清楚",
      "柱形改为更饱和的青绿单色，与浅色卡底拉开对比",
      "柱形高低对比更醒目，仍为卡内首要焦点"
    ],
    "preserve": [
      "连接入口保持可点击",
      "入口文字仍为连接手环手表",
      "只表达原有步数，不新增或改写数值",
      "仅单系列，不出现图例、量程底槽或第二指标",
      "标题、说明、图表、入口的板块从属不变",
      "卡片浅青渐变底与大圆角保持",
      "按钮描边色与胶囊圆角保持",
      "设备按钮仍位于柱形下方"
    ],
    "assign": [
      "图表卡大圆角、柱形均匀分布作用于步数柱形图",
      "本轮调整作用于步数柱形图"
    ],
    "ambiguities": [],
    "confidence": 0.87,
    "item_confidence": {
      "borrow": [
        0.85,
        0.88
      ],
      "assign": [
        0.86,
        0.86
      ],
      "apply": [
        0.86,
        0.88,
        0.86,
        0.87
      ],
      "preserve": [
        0.95,
        0.95,
        0.93,
        0.92,
        0.9,
        0.9,
        0.9,
        0.88
      ]
    },
    "ambiguity_suggestions": {}
  },
  "recorded_turns": [
    {
      "turn_id": "turn_001",
      "created_at": "2026-10-29T03:36:02.534+00:00",
      "mode": "analyze",
      "scope_status": "superseded_by_clarification",
      "clarifies_turn_id": null
    },
    {
      "turn_id": "turn_002",
      "created_at": "2026-10-29T03:45:25.124+00:00",
      "mode": "clarify",
      "scope_status": "confirmed",
      "clarifies_turn_id": "turn_001"
    }
  ],
  "before_provenance": "Before-negotiation output is an archived counterfactual generation from the initial plan, not an earlier live user-visible version.",
  "reply_provenance": "The clarification was submitted by the experiment script. This is not an independent participant usability study.",
  "observed_limit": "The confirmed output removes the legend and range slots and keeps nine bars, but bar heights still drift. Visible device entry does not establish a working device connection."
}